Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Return on Investment
  • August 17, 2004
2
WEALTH=Money Invested*(1+Return/Period)time money invested
  • Money Invested
  • Time Money Invested
  • Return per period
3
Professional’s Incentives
  • Our goal increase our wealth
  • Professional’s goal
    • Earn commission
    • Charge fee
    • Help client grow wealth
    • Keep boss happy
  • Professionals need pay
  • Make sure you know how pay calculated
  • Try to align their pay with your goals
4
Risk
  • Risk and uncertainty related
  • Risk is probability of something bad happening
  • Uncertainty is the unknown, the unquantifiable
  • Future
5
 
6
Day 3
  • Alternate to Reverse Mortgage
  • Retirement Draw
  • Real Estate vs Stock
  • Portfolio Recommendations
  • Beating the Market
    • Drach
    • Trend Reversion Portfolio Strategy
    • Shortcuts
  • Keys to Portfolio Management Success
  • Goals


7
Reverse Mortgage?
  • Monthly income
  • Balance climbs instead of falling
  • Pay off by selling
8
Alternative to Reverse Mortgage
  • Borrow max on real estate
  • Open portfolio account
  • Invest, in stocks
  • Pay monthly p&i out of portfolio account
  • Let it grow
  • Spend excess
9
Alternative to Reverse Mortgage
10
Alternative to Reverse Mortgage
11
Alternative to Reverse Mortgage
12
Alternative to Reverse Mortgage
13
Compare Monthly
  • Reverse Mortgage
    • Set income
  • Alternate
    • Variable appreciation
    • Set cash out (p&i)

14
Compare Terminus
  • Reverse Mortgage
    • Sell house to pay mortgage
  • Alternate
    • Mortgage paid off
    • Home free and clear
    • Money in account $130,000
15
Compare do nothing
16
Why doesn’t everybody do it?
17
Retirement Draw
  • Conventional Wisdom
    • Switch more of equity into bonds as retirement approaches
  • Hmmm!
    • Trading away higher return for lower risk
18
Retirement Draw
  • IRS ‘term certain’ method lets you spend the reciprocal of years left each year.
  • Years left is determined by actuarial tables.
  • Required after 70 ˝


19
 
20
Retirement Draw
21
 
22
 
23
Real Estate vs Stock
  • $100,000 to invest
  • Simply case
    • Real estate 4% (inflation)
    • Stocks 10% (pre 2000 history)
  • Leveraged case
    • $500,000 single family residence
    • 50% margin
24
Real estate
25
Stock investment -- $100,000 Margin
26
Stock investment 50% leverage
27
 
28
The South Sea Bubble
  • “Lesson from the past is keep your expectations realistic.  Don’t let promises of “sure-win” situations and “instant wealth” lure you from a consistent and disciplined investment strategy.
  • Investors today have access to vast stores of information.  Use this to your advantage.  Read books, go to seminars, or hire professionals.  Use you intuition as well.  If it seems too good to be true, it probably is.
  • …this need not mean investors become stodgy --  taking risks is essential to some payoff.  But calculated risk is a far cry from manic speculation”
29
Bernard Baruch
  • “…even in the very presence of dizzily spiraling prices, we had all continually repeated “two and two still make four” much of the evil might have been averted.
  • …even in the general moment of gloom in which this foreword is written, when many begin to wonder if the decline will never halt, the appropriate abracadabra may be: “They always do”
30
Specific
Portfolio Management Recommendations
  • Save more, delay consumption longer
  • Open a FOLIOfn account, ShareBuilder
  • Put everything in SPY -- slowly
  • Put everything in SPY, QQQ, DIA, EFA, EWJ  -- slowly
  • Subscribe to the Drach Market Letter, any market letter
  • Make an investment plan, write down goals, think thru some what ifs
  • Put some $ in beat the market strategies
31
Specific Recommendations
  • Put everything in SPY
  • Put everything in SPY, QQQ, DIA, EFA, EWJ
  • Subscribe to the Drach Market Letter
  • Put some in beat the market strategies
32
Specific Recommendations
  • Put everything in SPY
  • Put everything in SPY, QQQ, DIA, EFA, EWJ
  • Subscribe to the Drach Market Letter
  • Put some in beat the market strategies
33
ETFs
  • Passively managed portfolio of stocks, usually designed to mimic an index.
  • Priced and traded throughout the day. They offer all the flexibility of stocks: They can be purchased with market, limit or stop-loss orders; can be short-sold; and can be traded on margin.
  • Like stocks and unlike mutual funds, there are options based on them.
  • Don't have much asset turnover, their fees are lower than even the most cost-efficient index mutual funds. For example, the first-ever ETFs, Standard & Poor's Depositary Receipts (SPY), known as Spiders, carry a lean and mean expense ratio of 0.12%.
  • Less tax consequence and trading cost than Mutual Funds


34
Large ETFs
35
Fixed Income ETFs
  • The ETF Advisors line-up includes:
    • 1-year FITR (TFT),
    • 2-year FITR (TOU),
    • 5-year FITR (TFI), and
    • 10-year FITR (TTE).
  • iShares funds
    • 1- to 3-year (SHY),
    • 7- to 10-year (IEF),
    • 20+ year (TLT).
36
Indexing
37
Beat the Market Strategies
  • Discretionary
    • News, Hot Tips, gut
  • Fundamental
    • Good company, good stock investment
  • Technical
    • Charts, indicators, price action
  • System
    • Manage
      • Cash
      • Risk
      • Portfolio
38
Beat the Market Strategies
  • Fundamental, CFA
    • Buy into the company
    • Good company = good stock
    • analysts project earnings, Target Price determined from discounting future cash flow
  • Technical, MTA
    • Price and volume
    • Past movement used to forecasts future/target price
    • Momentum
    • Reversal
39
Approaches to Investing in Equities
  • Disciplines can be complementary
  • Money management professionals often use some combination of the three
    •  Emphasis varies
    •  A matter of personal preference
40
Future
  • Professionals
    • Weather forecasters
    • Book makers
    • Urban Planners
    • Corporate Strategic Planners
    • Iraqi occupation planners
    • Economists
    • John Naisbitt “Megatrends”
    • Danny Devito’s football pool



41
Drach
  • Robert F. Drach
  • Master List
    • Fundamental
  • Market Timing
    • Quantitative, market indicators
  • Buys and Sells
    • Technical
42
Drach Timing
43
Drach vs S&P 500
44
 
45
Plan
  • 1) Develop Model (PLAN)
    • A)Build Model
      • Pick a group of equities
      • Build method to sort equities from most oversold to most overbought.
      • Structure model to buy equities that are oversold, and maybe, short equities that are most overbought
      • Structure model to adjust equity level appropriate for position of market in its cycle.
      • Fill model with price, and/or indicator history.
    • B) Test the Model
    • C) Tune the Model
    • D) Repeat A through C Until 'Ready to Trade‘
  • 2) Trade the Model (EXECUTE)
  • 3) Monitor Portfolio Performance (FEEDBACK)
  • 4) Repeat 1 through 3 Until all your money is working.
  • 5) Switch Models, evolve with market
46
Trend Regression Portfolio Management
  • Master List
    • Stocks you like, Fundamental
    • Stocks expected to move together
  • Market Timing
    • 100% Long
  • Buys and Sells
    • Reversals
47
Master List
  • Screens
    • Growth, history and projected
    • Consistency of earnings
    • Value
      • p/e
      • p/s
      • Dividend yield
    • R2
    • Correlation
48
Market Timing
  • Buy when?
  • Stock ratio
    • Stocks as % account equity
  • Adjust stock ratio based on
    • Market
    • vs
    • Investor’s age
49
Market Timing
  • Buy when everybody else is selling
    • Everybody = general public
    • Not insiders or smart money
  • Sell when everybody else is buying
50
Market Timing -- BUY
  • P/Es are falling
  • Price Volatility is increasing.
  • The Press is negative:  Doom and Gloom in headlines.
  • Trend Analysis:  Prices go below the 180-day moving average.
  • Believed Cause and Effect.  Interest rates and gold prices rising.
  • Volume: Market volume increases by 15 % or greater.
51
 
52
Market Timing – SELL
  • P/Es are climbing.  75 % of P/Es have shifted higher.
  • Price Volatility increasing.
  • Press is positive, reporting how wonderful market is.
  • Trend: Majority of stocks over 180-day moving average.
  • Cause and Effect: Interest Rates and Gold Prices both declining.
  • Overall Market Volume up by 15% or greater.
53
Market Timing
  • 100% long
  • Drach
  • “It is a common perception that the market provides a constant rate of return when in fact almost all truly successful strategies share the common characteristic that around 80% of the profit is attained in around 20% of the time.”


54
Buys and Sells
  • Where is stock price relative to other stocks in model?
  • Buy/sell those most depressed?
55
Beat the Market Strategies
  • Momentum
  • Reversal
  • Buy and Hold
56
Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy
  • Based on reversion to the mean, reversal
  • Bernard Baruch’s “They always do”
57
Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy -- Model
  • 50 equities
  • 540 data points (10 years of weekly OHLCV)
  • Optimizes smoothing weeks
  • Built with Excel, VBA
58
Findings A
    • Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy seems to work, in all but 2 of the back-tests discussed so far, following an optimized Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy gained more than a buy and hold strategy for the model’s 50 equities.
    • Hedging and Timing impact performance, but don’t necessarily improve the performance over staying 100% Long.
    • Some optimizations seem quite robust as shown by the Smoothing-weeks, Proportion Timed colored grid and by the 3-year and 10-year tests for HILO equities optimizing at same Smoothing-weeks, Proportion Timed combination.
    • Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy works better for longer time-periods, i.e. the longer it is used.
59
Findings B
    • For longer tests, Relative Gain and Index Gain are inversely correlated, as Index Gain decreases Relative Gain increases.  Therefore, Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy reduces drawdown as relatively speaking; the model works best in a bear market.
    • Short duration optimizations may produce high future returns.  However, historic short duration optimizations cannot yield better returns than historic longer period optimizations for the longer historic period, if the shorter period is contained in the longer period.
    • Not only is model performance, TRiPS%, sensitive to indicator sort order, it seems performance is generally better for reversal (ascending sorts), than for trend following (descending sorts).
    • There are times when trend following will produce better performance than reversal.
60
Findings C
    • Stock picking, selection of 50 equities to track in a model, has a big impact on the Trend Regression Strategy Portfolio model’s performance.
    • There is more than one way to select groups that yield tradable performance, TRiPS% over 1.0%.
    • Groupings that seem intuitively to have potential don’t necessarily produce good back-test results.
61
Findings D
    • Choice, of which indicators to use for generating buy and sell signals, has a big impact on model performance.
    • The same indicator is not likely to be best for all models.
    • More than one indicator has yielded tradable performance, that is, TRiPS% over 1.0%.
    • Sometimes the right indicator can save a group from extinction.
    • The best indicator in back-tests is not necessarily the best indicator for the future.
62
Findings E
    • Market Timing can influence Trend Regression Strategy Portfolio model performance.
    • Choice of indicator has an impact on success of market timing.
    • Match-up of Trend Regression Portfolio Strategy group and indicator is important to the success of market timing.  It doesn’t appear that there is one indicator that will work regardless of the group.
    • Many models optimize at 100% long all the time.
63
Backtest - Optimize
  • Optimize over as long a data set as possible.
  • Use as few parameters as possible.
  • Bias yourself to systems that show robustness across parameters.
  • Forward test—preferably using the anchored technique of forward testing to be consistent with rule 1.
  • Identify the region of parameter values that appears to be the peak, and pick the parameter with lowest performance value therein that has higher performance values for the parameters on either side.  Ideally you will have the same parameter values for all markets you are trading a given system on.”
  • Once you start trading a system, resist re-optimizing or retuning.
64
What‘s verdict on optimization?
65
Shortcut
  • Screen Fundamentals
  • Screen Technical
  • Stay 100% long
  • Hedge
  • Paper-trade if you can’t backtest
66
SCREENS
  • http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/finder/customstocks.asp
  • http://search.wallstreetcity.com/wsc2/prosearch.html
67
Keys to Portfolio Success
  • Internalize Wealth Formula
    • Invest more
    • Leave $ invest longer (defer gratification)
    • Get higher return (accept risk)
  • Reduce Expense
    • Fees and transaction cost
  • Manage Risk
    • Diversification mitigates risk
    • Time mitigates risk
    • Testing mitigates risk
68
Keys to Success - II
  • Strategy counts
    • Good strategy beats random
    • Bad strategy loses to market
    • ETFs match market
  • Good Strategies
    • Drach
    • Trend Regression Portfolio Management
    • Come and Go
69
Goal(s)
  • What’s important to you
    • Die rich vs. die broke
    • Work forever vs. retire early
    • Spend now vs. delayed gratification
    • Independence, responsibility
  • Less than 5% of people have their goals written down. Only 5% of people are truly successful in life. Is there a correlation? When Alice asked the Cheshire Cat which road to take, he asked, "Where do you want to go?" Alice said, "I don't rightly know," to which he astutely answered, "If you don't know where you want to go, then either road will get you there." -- Write it Down, Donnie McKinney


70
"lyle@diyportfoliomanagement.com"
  • lyle@diyportfoliomanagement.com
  • Feedback
  • World’s best Money Managers http://www.nelsoninformation.com/wbmm/login.asp
  • Education Opportunities http://www.morningstar.com
  • The Money Machine


71
 
72